The other day Thing 2 ran up to me in Wegmans and handed me a packaged cookie. “It’s dairy-free, egg-free, soy-free and gluten-free, Mommy!” he beamed. “Can we get some?” It felt like a hockey puck in a plastic sack. “I think this one might be fun-free, Buddy,” I said as I put it back on a shelf filled with other “everything-free” treats.
I have given up a lot in pursuit of good health. Meat went first, more than 15 years ago. More recently I gave up eggs and dairy (and blue cheese, heaven help me) as I transitioned to an almost completely vegan diet (I cheat with marshmallows and the rare egg and dairy when traveling). I drew the line at gluten, however.
I did try. So many health gurus have been spouting off the benefits of gluten free living that I decided to see what it does for me. Perhaps I was one of those unfortunate souls with a hidden gluten sensitivity! Perhaps it would came me to miraculously drop those last 10 pounds!
I found instead that it made me miserable with no benefit to my health. I did not feel better, but I did feel deprived. It’s not that you can’t have wonderful vegan, gluten-free food, but it takes soooooooooooooo much work for so little reward for someone who doesn’t have a gluten allergy.
It would seem that Doctor Furhman agrees that while gluten is a problem for some, avoiding gluten is not worth the effort for most of us:
Does Going Gluten-Free Equal Fabulously Healthy or Fabulously Foolish? : Disease Proof.
So if you’ve been thinking about giving up gluten, there’s two things you should know:
1. It’s going to be really tough. Gluten hides everywhere. It’s not just in bread and cookies, but also in beer, soups, spices mixtures, and even in envelope glue.
2. If you buy gluten free substitutes for traditional wheat products, it won’t help you lose weight. Often the gluten free version has more calories, as the manufacturer ups the fat and sugar to compensate for the tougher texture.
Despite this, I do include some gluten-free items in my pantry, in part because I came to like them, and in part because I have a friend who cannot eat gluten for genuine medical reasons. I love brown rice pasta. I will make “oatmeal” with quinoa instead of oats. My gluten free-chocolate cupcakes are as good as the wheat version.
But my seitan is all gluten, and my pizza crusts are whole wheat. That’s fine for my system, because I am in the 90% that has no problem with gluten.
